In an offseason already defined by unexpected transfer portal departures and speculation surrounding returning players, Memphis Tigers head coach Penny Hardaway made headlines not for a roster move but for his brutally honest assessment of college basketball’s shifting landscape.
Speaking at a media event on the University of Memphis campus, Hardaway addressed the recent news that star guard PJ Haggerty had entered the transfer portal, the eligibility uncertainty of forward Dain Dainja, and most notably, the chaos being created by the current Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) system. And while he remained respectful and diplomatic throughout the conversation, one message rang clear: Penny Hardaway believes college basketball is on the verge of a financial tipping point.
NIL in 2024: A Free Market Gone Wild?
“It’s crazy and out of hand,” Hardaway said when asked about the soaring NIL demands in this year’s transfer cycle. “This summer is way different than any other… and I don’t know how it got to that, but it’s there.”
There’s no denying it: NIL has fundamentally changed how college coaches build rosters. The days of long-term player development have given way to short-term recruiting wins, last-minute roster flips, and a dizzying arms race fueled by deep-pocketed boosters and high-stakes collectives. And while Hardaway firmly believes in players receiving compensation—a stance he’s consistently held—he also sees a system spiraling dangerously close to dysfunction.
“We all say the same thing, right? All in support of players getting paid. But this is out of control right now,” he added.
Memphis HC Penny Hardaway on PJ Haggerty entering transfer portal:
“I don’t think there was any disrespect to our university at all. PJ and I and his father have a great relationship. I think that he’s really, fully focusing on the NBA. … He didn’t close the door on us.” pic.twitter.com/Yje6NaPHNC
— Parth Upadhyaya (@pupadhyaya_) April 22, 2025
The Haggerty Situation: A Symptom of the Larger Problem
PJ Haggerty’s decision to enter the transfer portal sparked speculation about whether it was driven by NBA aspirations, NIL offers elsewhere, or a combination of both. For Hardaway, the explanation was simple, but the circumstances are emblematic of today’s climate.
“There was no disrespect to our university at all,” said Hardaway, who maintained a positive relationship with Haggerty and his family. “He’s focusing on the NBA. But he didn’t close the door on us.”
The problem isn’t that Haggerty left the door open—it’s that Memphis has to wait, and in the meantime, talented prospects in the portal are being scooped up by programs with more money, faster offers, or more aggressive NIL collectives. “It makes it a little tougher,” Hardaway admitted. “Other players in the portal aren’t waiting.”
Dainja’s Eligibility Limbo Adds Another Layer
Then there’s the Dain Dainja situation, which adds another wrinkle to Memphis’ offseason strategy. Dainja is technically out of eligibility, but the program hopes for a waiver to allow him to return for another year. Hardaway didn’t dive into the social media chatter surrounding Dainja’s brief appearance in the portal last week, but he voiced hope that the NCAA will rule in the Tigers’ favor.
“You’d hope they show favor to Dain,” Hardaway said. “There are guys getting six, seven, eight years. I don’t know how they decide these things.”
Whether Dainja returns or not, the ambiguity makes roster planning even more difficult, especially when combined with the NIL chaos and transfer unpredictability already in play.
The Bigger Picture: Can This Continue?
One of the most compelling parts of Hardaway’s comments was his concern about where the sport is headed if this trend continues unchecked.
“How long is this going to go?” he asked. “We’re almost there… Some of these numbers are crazy.”
When asked if he worries that college basketball could spiral into a place of “no return,” Hardaway didn’t flinch: “I mean, we’re almost there.”
These comments echo a growing sentiment among college coaches. NIL was supposed to level the playing field, rewarding players for their brand and likeness, not becoming an outright bidding war for the highest bidder. However, the lines between compensation and recruitment have blurred to the point where building a team is more about financial leverage than coaching ability.
The Memphis Factor: Still a City United
Hardaway expresses deep appreciation for the Memphis community, boosters, and donors despite the frustration. “We have a great group of supporters and donors,” he said. “It’s just a positive situation for our city. We’re all together here.”
Still, he left it clear that the Tigers—like most non-Power 4 programs—are now forced to navigate a ruthless offseason terrain where loyalty is no longer guaranteed and NIL dollars can easily outweigh tradition, coaching relationships, or even championship potential.
Hardaway’s remarks should serve as a wake-up call—not just to fans of Memphis basketball, but to the broader college hoops community. In a system that increasingly favors money over merit and influence over infrastructure, even programs with a rich history and national relevance like Memphis are being squeezed by a market they didn’t create.
Hardaway will continue to do what he’s done since taking over the program: adapt, recruit, and compete. But his comments make it clear—unless guardrails are established, the identity of college basketball could change permanently.
And Penny, like many others, isn’t sure what that version of the sport will look like.
Subscribe on YouTube
Don’t miss out on the latest and greatest content surrounding the Memphis Tigers! Stay connected and up to date by liking, commenting, and subscribing to our YouTube channel, Memphis Wire. Doing so ensures you never miss a beat regarding news, highlights, analysis, and interviews related to your favorite teams. Whether you’re a die-hard fan or simply love following the action, our channel is your go-to destination for all things Memphis Tigers. So, hit that like button, leave a comment to join the conversation, and subscribe to Memphis Wire to ensure you’re always in the loop!
