The NFL has never been more unforgiving when it comes to developing quarterbacks. Patience used to be a virtue. Now? It’s a luxury few franchises — or head coaches — can afford. The 2024 season saw a historic wave of rookie quarterbacks taking the reins from Day 1. Four quarterbacks selected in the top 12 picks started almost immediately. And now, entering 2025, the league’s climate has grown even less tolerant of slow burns or “developmental” timelines. So, where does that leave the New Orleans Saints?
It’s a question Kellen Moore — the newly hired head coach following the midseason firing of Dennis Allen in 2024 — must answer quickly. The Saints enter training camp with a quarterback room that includes rookie Tyler Shough, former South Carolina and Oklahoma star Spencer Rattler, and third-year signal-caller Jake Haener. It’s a crowded room with no clear-cut starter, but a ton of intrigue.
The NFL’s Instant Gratification Era
Let’s be clear: the Saints aren’t alone in their uncertainty. The 2024 rookie class reshaped the conversation around how soon a quarterback should start. Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels, Drake Maye, Bo Nix, and Michael Penix Jr. were all thrown into the fire. Results varied, but the underlying message was clear — teams want answers now. Fans, media, and even ownership often force the issue, pushing rookies into roles they may or may not be ready for. Only Daniels and Nix led their teams to the playoffs out of the five quarterbacks mentioned.
That shift in league philosophy could have a ripple effect in New Orleans. While Tyler Shough is currently expected to be the Week 1 starter, Kellen Moore’s offense and long-term plans could favor someone like Rattler, who offers a different set of tools and temperament — or even Haener, if he surprises during camp.
But the Saints’ biggest challenge might not be internal competition. It’s the external pressure of expectation, and how fast the fanbase and local media want to see results.
A New Direction Under Kellen Moore
The decision to move on from Dennis Allen midway through 2024 was a long time coming. The Saints were lifeless offensively, stale schematically, and unable to develop a long-term solution at quarterback. Derek Carr’s abrupt retirement due to a shoulder injury only accelerated the transition.
Enter Kellen Moore, the offensive-minded head coach tasked with modernizing a franchise long anchored by its defense under Allen. Moore brings a résumé that includes helping shape the early success of Justin Herbert, Dak Prescott, and most recently, Jalen Hurts. In New Orleans, he’ll need to evaluate and mold a room full of question marks into a long-term solution.
Shough, the rookie from Louisville, brings size, toughness, and arm strength. Once projected as a first-round pick before a bumpy college career, Rattler arrives with valuable experience and an edge. Haener, the holdover from the Carr era, has flashed at times but hasn’t separated himself.
It’s a good problem to have, three viable options. But it’s also a political one. Fans will demand clarity. And Moore must resist the urge to rush development to calm the noise.
Who’s the Most NFL-Ready?
Tyler Shough has the prototypical size and traits you’d want in a modern quarterback. However, injuries and inconsistency in college leave questions about his ability to handle the speed and complexity of NFL defenses. He’s more of a projection than a plug-and-play option.
Spencer Rattler, meanwhile, may be the most prepared from a pure in-game reps standpoint. He’s played in multiple systems, in the SEC and Big 12, and often under immense pressure. He’s battle-tested. His arm talent is real. His processing has improved. And he doesn’t lack confidence, something this Saints locker room could use more of.
Then there’s Jake Haener — the forgotten man in this race, but he’s fighting an uphill battle regarding raw talent and ceiling. Still, he’s the type of quarterback who could hang around if the other two fail to separate.
Is Patience Possible in New Orleans?
This is the existential question facing the franchise.
With a new coach, a restructured offense, and a fanbase starving for relevance, can the Saints afford to give their young quarterbacks time? Or will they be forced to pick a lane and hope for the best, like many others around the league?
There’s a compelling argument for letting the competition play out naturally. Unlike teams that drafted Caleb Williams or Jayden Daniels with top-five picks, the Saints don’t have millions of dollars and public expectation invested in a single golden-armed savior. They can truly let the best man win.
At the same time, the NFL doesn’t wait. If Shough starts slow or looks overwhelmed, calls for Rattler will start before Week 4. If Rattler looks sharp in preseason but doesn’t get the nod, Moore could answer tough questions from day one. The microscope is intense and unforgiving.
What Does Success Look Like?
This season isn’t about making a playoff run. It’s about identifying the future. If Kellen Moore can exit 2025 with confidence in his quarterback room, knowing who can and can’t lead this team, the year will be a success.
He must avoid quarterback purgatory: shuffling through all three without finding a leader. That’s how coaching tenures get cut short, and how rebuilds become reboots.
The upside is that Moore has the autonomy and job security to take a true developmental approach. The front office knows this is a long-term build, not a quick fix. If that philosophy can hold, the Saints may finally find their answer under center, not in one preseason, but over a full year.
Show Your Support
Support the great work of the Saints on Sports View 360 by purchasing licensed NFL fan gear. Items ranged from Saints hats, jerseys, t-shirts, socks, and more. We would greatly appreciate it if you would buy these items from the text link listed below. The revenue generated from today’s offer goes into the funding of the Sports View 360. Click on the link below if you are interested.
New Orleans Saints Fan Gear Deals at Fanatics
