The 2024 Memphis Tigers closed the book on their season with a 42-37 victory over West Virginia in the Frisco Bowl, capturing their first-ever 11-win campaign and solidifying their place among the elite Group of Five programs. But as quickly as one chapter ended, another began, with a roster overhaul that few outside the program saw coming.
When spring practice opens for the 2025 season, Memphis will field a drastically new squad, largely thanks to one of the country’s most aggressive transfer portal hauls. According to CBS Sports, the Tigers were ranked second nationally among Group of Five programs in transfer portal success, behind only James Madison. Over 30 new players, including talent from Power Four programs and FCS All-Americans, have been added to the roster. The big question looming over the Bluff City is: Can this completely retooled Memphis roster contend immediately?
The Context: Why the Overhaul Was Necessary
Memphis’ success in 2024 was built on veteran leadership and continuity, most notably from quarterback Seth Henigan, the program’s all-time leading passer, and a core group of defensive starters who brought experience and consistency. But with Henigan moving on and not a single starter returning from the 2024 defensive opener, a massive retooling became a necessity rather than a luxury.
That reality put head coach Ryan Silverfield and his staff in the hot seat early in the offseason. But rather than panic, Memphis responded with purpose. With strong NIL backing, headlined by a reported $5 million investment from FedEx, the Tigers quickly became one of the portal’s most active and effective programs. The challenge now isn’t just replacing talent—it’s making that talent gel into a competitive team before Week 1.
The Offense: New Faces, Familiar Expectations
Replacing Henigan was priority No. 1, and Memphis wasted little time securing a potential answer. Brendon Lewis, a transfer quarterback from Nevada, enters with five years of collegiate experience and a reputation as a dynamic dual-threat option. While not as polished in the passing game as Henigan, Lewis brings a level of athleticism and mobility that could add a new wrinkle to the Tigers’ offensive playbook.
Lewis may compensate for what he lacks in arm talent with his ability to extend plays and open up running lanes for Memphis’ skill players. Still, building chemistry with an almost entirely new receiving corps will be critical. With standouts like Roc Taylor, Koby Drake, and DeMeer Blankumsee gone, Memphis will rely heavily on portal additions and underclassmen to step up.
The running game remains a potential area of strength. Memphis has continued to show it can develop quality backs in-house, and any consistency in that area will take pressure off Lewis as he adapts to a new system.
The Defense: From Ground Zero to Gateway?
Nowhere will the change be more evident than on defense. With no Week 1 starters from 2024 returning, this unit was built from scratch. That would be cause for concern for most programs, but Memphis isn’t approaching this like most programs.
Headlining the new arrivals is edge rusher A.J. Pena, a 2024 FCS All-American who recorded 12.5 sacks and 22.5 tackles for loss at Rhode Island. Pena could immediately anchor the defensive line and provide the disruptive presence that Memphis lacked in big games.
The Tigers also added experienced Power Four linemen like Rayyan Buell (Colorado) and Marcus Burris Jr. (Indiana), who bring the size, athleticism, and pedigree needed to compete in the trenches.
In the secondary, Memphis loaded up with playmakers such as Omarion Cooper (Florida State) and Chauncey Logan Jr. (James Madison). Cooper brings length and ACC-level experience, while Logan was part of a JMU defense that made waves nationally in 2023 and 2024. Together, they could form the foundation of a secondary that will be tested early and often.
The challenge, however, isn’t just talent—it’s cohesion. Defensive coordinator Jordon Hankins must develop a unit that communicates well, tackles consistently, and understands each other’s tendencies in real time. That doesn’t happen overnight.
The Coaching Factor: Silverfield’s Biggest Test Yet
Ryan Silverfield has steadily elevated the Memphis program since taking over in 2020, culminating each year in bowl eligibility and, in recent years, showcasing real national relevance. But 2025 presents his toughest challenge yet. Integrating over 30 new players while maintaining a standard of excellence is no small feat.
The good news is that Silverfield has built credibility within the program, among recruits, and with boosters. The NIL strategy is in place, the transfer pitch is working, and Memphis is no longer seen as a stepping stone—it’s a legitimate destination.
Success in 2025 will depend on how quickly this roster comes together. With key early matchups against Chattanooga, Troy, and an SEC showdown against Arkansas, Memphis doesn’t have the luxury of a slow start.
The Intangibles: Culture, Chemistry, and Buy-In
Beyond Xs and Os, the real deciding factor in Memphis’s ability to contend may be how well the locker room unites. Chemistry is often overlooked in transfer-heavy programs, but it can be the difference between a promising season and a disappointing one.
Building a cohesive team culture with many new faces will require intentional leadership from coaches and returning players. The Tigers will need quick buy-in from transfers who may only be around for a year or two. During spring and fall camp, trust, accountability, and internal competition will be buzzwords.
Final Thoughts: The Path Is Narrow, But Doable
Memphis isn’t backing down from expectations in 2025—they’re leaning into them. The Tigers are positioned to compete with one of the top transfer classes in the nation, with strong NIL support and a coaching staff that has proven it can win.
But let’s be clear: the margin for error is razor-thin. Early cohesion, newcomers’ leadership, and immediate defense production will determine whether Memphis is in the AAC title hunt or playing catch-up.
The Tigers may look different in 2025, but the goal remains the same: win now. And if this new-look roster can find its rhythm early, Memphis might be the surprise contender the AAC didn’t see coming.
Show Your Support
Show your support for the Memphis Wire on Sports View 360 by exploring and purchasing licensed NCAA fan gear. From stylish Memphis hats, jerseys, and t-shirts to cozy socks and much more, our collection offers a range of options to showcase your team spirit. By purchasing through the text link provided below, you contribute to the funding of the Sports View 360 platform, enabling us to continue providing comprehensive coverage and engaging content. If interested, click the link below and browse our Memphis Tigers fan gear selection. Your support is greatly appreciated.
Memphis Tigers Fan Gear Offers from Fanatics.com
